The Maple Old Fashioned Cocktail is one of the most crowd pleasing whiskey cocktails in the game. Mantry helps curate you the best ingredients for Maple Cocktail heaven.

Best Cherries For Old Fashioned Cocktail?

When you're going for the perfect Old Fashioned, premium cocktail cherries make a huge difference. Look no further than Amarena Fabri Cherries which are made in Italy, make any cocktail special and make you look pretty sweet as you dig a spoon into the beautiful packaging. Black cherries for old fashioned drinking should be really special and exciting. Amarena Fabri fits the bill. This also doubles as a champagne cocktail cherry, manhattan cocktail cherry and our personal favorite, ice cream cocktail cherry. 

If you want to stiff the Italians here is our list of the 5 Best American-Made Cocktail Cherries.

Best Maple Syrup For Old Fashioned Cocktail?

Runamok® Maple Bourbon Barrel-Aged Maple Syrup – The Creamery

One of the wonderful things about making a Maple Syrup Old Fashioned is not having to fuss with making a simple syrup.  How do you make the best Maple Syrup Old Fashioned? Use the best Maple Syrup. We love Runamok Bourbon Barrel Aged Maple Syrup, we won't bore you with the details, leave it to the maker who explains better...

From the Maker:

"Our barrel-aged maple syrups are 100% pure Vermont maple aged in rye whiskey, bourbon, and rum barrels. Delicious on pancakes, ice cream, and pretty much anything else you can think of. Qualifying orders ship free"

Best Bitters For Maple Old Fashioned?

Don't fool around, Angostura Bitters works just fine.

Best Whiskey For Maple Old Fashioned?

Ater 10 years of running the Mantry subscription and curating thousands of small-batch products, nothing boils people's blood like the great whiskey debate.  The appropriate answer to this question is either the whiskey (be it rye or bourbon or whatever) you enjoy or the best whisky you can get your hands on.  We will submit that you might as well use Canadian Whiskey, this is a Maple Old Fashioned after all (sorry Vermont).

Want a great recipe? Shout out to The Delicious Spoon, who might have the best Maple Old Fashioned Recipe around.


Give him the gift he really wants - including 6 full-size artisan food products and a custom handmade wooden crate.

give him a gift


We'll deliver the best foods from across the country to your door every two months.

subscribe today